Skip to content

New: 9 Mountains partners with Royal Holloway’s Data Analysis for Charities Lab - Discover more

Has your charity outgrown its team structure 1 1

Has your charity outgrown its team structure?

A charity’s team structure can become outdated as it grows, leading to unclear responsibilities, overloaded managers and over-reliance on the CEO. Reviewing roles, reporting lines and decision-making can help ensure the organisation has the right structure to support sustainable growth.

Many charities do not redesign their team structure in one clear moment.

It changes gradually.

A staff member takes on extra responsibilities because they are capable. A manager starts supervising more people than originally planned. A project grows, but the reporting line stays the same. The CEO remains involved in decisions that should now sit elsewhere. A role becomes part delivery, part operations, part fundraising, part administration.

At first, this flexibility can be useful. It helps a small charity adapt quickly and keep moving.

But over time, the structure that helped the charity grow can start to hold it back.

The problem is not always that the charity needs more staff. Sometimes the deeper issue is that roles, reporting lines and responsibilities no longer match the work being done.

When this happens, pressure often shows up in familiar ways.

People are busy, but no one is quite sure who owns a decision. Managers are responsible for outcomes but do not have enough authority or time. Staff go to the CEO for things that should be handled by their line manager. Two people are partly responsible for the same area, so gaps and duplication appear. Some roles quietly expand, while others remain narrowly defined.

The organisation keeps functioning, but it becomes harder to lead.

This is an HR issue, but it is also a strategic one. Team structure affects service delivery, staff retention, decision-making, accountability and growth. If the structure is unclear, people may work hard without the organisation becoming stronger.

One warning sign is role drift.

This happens when someone’s actual job has moved far beyond their job description. They may have taken on supervision, partnership work, compliance tasks, volunteer management or operational responsibilities without the role being formally reviewed.

Role drift can be flattering at first. It often happens because someone is trusted. But if it is not recognised, it can become unfair. The person may be carrying more responsibility without the right pay, authority, support or clarity. Other staff may also become unsure where responsibilities sit.

Another warning sign is a crowded centre.

In many growing charities, too much still flows through the CEO or founder. Staff seek approval, trustees ask operational questions, managers escalate routine issues, and external relationships depend on one person.

This may be manageable at small scale. But as the charity grows, it creates a bottleneck. Decisions slow down, senior leaders become overloaded and the organisation becomes vulnerable if one person is unavailable.

A third warning sign is unclear management.

A team member may technically report to one person, but receive direction from several others. A manager may be expected to lead people without enough time set aside for management. Staff may not know who to go to for priorities, support or decisions.

These issues can quietly weaken culture. People become frustrated not because they lack commitment, but because the structure makes good work harder than it needs to be.

The answer is not always a restructure in the formal, intimidating sense of the word. Sometimes what is needed is simply a clearer picture of how the charity now works.

That starts with mapping reality.

What roles actually exist, not just what the chart says? Who manages whom? Who makes which decisions? Where do staff go for support? Which roles have grown? Where is work duplicated? Which responsibilities have no clear owner? Where is the CEO still holding too much?

This exercise can be revealing because the formal structure and the real structure are often different.

Once the reality is visible, leaders can decide what needs to change. That might mean rewriting job descriptions, clarifying line management, creating a new coordinator role, moving responsibilities away from the CEO, reducing duplication, or giving managers more authority and support.

It may also mean recognising that a role has become too large for one person. In that case, recruitment may be needed – but recruitment should follow the structure, not substitute for it.

This is where some charities make a mistake. They feel pressure, so they add a new post. But if responsibilities, workflows and reporting lines remain unclear, the new role can add complexity rather than solve the problem.

A better question is: what structure does the charity need for the next stage?

Trustees have an important role in this. They do not need to design every job description, but they should understand whether the current structure is sustainable. If the CEO is carrying too much, if key roles are unclear, or if growth depends on informal workarounds, the board needs to know.

This is especially important when charities are seeking funding for new posts. A funder may support a role, but the charity still needs to show how that post fits into the wider model. Otherwise, new funding can create short-term capacity without solving the underlying organisational issue.

A healthy team structure does not need to be complicated. It needs to be clear enough for people to do good work.

Staff should understand what they are responsible for. Managers should have enough time and authority to lead. The CEO should not be the default answer to every operational question. Trustees should have assurance that the structure supports the charity’s strategy, rather than relying on informal stretch.

A practical starting point is to ask three questions.

What has changed since the current structure was created? Where are decisions, people or responsibilities getting stuck? What structure would make delivery easier, fairer and more sustainable?

If the answers are unclear, the charity may not need a bigger team straight away. It may need a better-designed one.

At 9 Mountains, we help charities look across HR, service delivery, finance, governance and strategy so team structures keep pace with organisational growth. The aim is not to create hierarchy for its own sake. It is to make sure people have the clarity, support and authority they need for the climb ahead.

Get more guidance like this

If you’d like regular, practical help for the journey, our Charity Trail Cards deliver short, actionable tools straight to your inbox, one clear step to steady your organisation each week.